Inept Recruiter Rejects Technical Writer With 8 Years of Experience For Being 'Too Inexperienced'

Advertisement
  • 01
    Font - S1 r/antiwork u/Saarnath 1d. i.redd.it They invited me for a first interview and it went awesome... I asked the next person in line why she rejected me and she hit me with this. (I have 8 years of experience as a technical writer)
  • 02
    Motor vehicle - HIRING TODAY 12:52 PM Hi. This position is only relevant for candidates with proven experience in Technical Writing or relevant certification. I didn't see indication of those in your profile. While I believe strongly in mentoring and servant leadership, unfortunately at this time I and my team are under too much pressure to be able to help a new person ramp up entirely.
  • 03
    Font - Saarnath OP. 1d 1 Award Then she admitted she didn't even look at my resume. My response: I have eight years of experience as a technical writer and submitted a robust portfolio along with my resume. Although we may not use the same tools, that doesn't make my experience any less valid. If you aren't willing to train, I would recommend screening your candidates for your desired software proficiencies before extending interview invitations in the future.
  • 04
    Font - Her: I'd typically continue this conversation with you and request your CV, but you sound angry.. And like you're trying to teach me something ... which is not appealing to me as a hiring manager. Gross. ... Reply 3.1k
  • 05
    Font - chaseinger 23h ● but you sound angry that's all you need to know. immediate personal emotional response to a mistake they made. but then you're trying to teach me something oh no, god forbid. /s nail in the coffin right there. s 42.1k
  • 06
    Font - Extravidrigt 17h ● "Your emotional response to your mistake is not my responsibility. Any professional in any setting will benefit from continuing to learn from their potential colleagues and peers. I wish you a good day." ... 4206 206
  • 07
    Rectangle - shgrdrbr. 17h saving thatttt 26
  • 08
    Mammal - MaleficentExtent1777 • 21h Good employees can ALWAYS teach the manager something! I've learned so much from my team members. 817
  • 09
    Font - putalotoftussinonit. 20h God yes! I love our paid interns as they always have some off-the-wall new way of doing the same old bill shit and it's awesome! Our GIS database is unbelievable and automated like no tomorrow because of stoner interns who we say yes to their ideas. ... 4278
  • 10
    Font - AbsolutStoli148. 16h lol...that reminds me of that quote about hiring lazy people. because they're the ones who will find creative ways of getting the job done by doing the least work possible. ... 193
  • 11
    Font - Saarnath OP. 20h Yes, that was the line that made me realize it was a good thing I didn't end up interacting with this person on a daily basis. The complete unwillingness to learn. I can spot a brick wall from a mile away and I'm so done with these types of people. No one is above learning. Imo you can literally learn from anyone if you're observant/insightful enough 4289
  • 12
    Rectangle - coldbloodedjelydonut. 16h I'd send this to someone higher up and let them know their hiring managers are bunging things up. ... 129
  • 13
    Font - disruptioncoin. 14h I second this. I can't imagine anyone with half a brain seeing this and thinking they handled any part of that situation well. ... 59
  • 14
    Font - PLACE Ralphie99 This is how my wife's nightmare of a boss ended up getting fired. She acted like a total ass to a well-qualified candidate for a position and the candidate emailed her boss all of the insulting emails she had sent him. This lead to an investigation and she was fired after they interviewed her staff and they all reported similar abusive behaviour. 8h ● 46
  • 15
    Font - tdi4u • 7h Agreed. Made me think of that old saw, Everyone is useful to us, if only as a bad example. "You learned plenty from her, and it was useful information. Too bad for their organization that she can't do the same, but you dodged a bullet. 47 7 ↓
  • 16
    Font - Saarnath OP. 7h Seriously, some of the most important stuff I know I learned from bad situations and totally random people. I still remember stuff my coworkers said like 8 years ago. I can't imagine going through life just blowing everyone off because you're a hiring manager or whatever. Even if you're a CEO. The point at which you stop learning is the point at which your brain goes numb 17
  • 17
    Font - tdi4u • 7h All true. I have had a ton of different jobs in my life. Maintenance guy, machine shop and then foundry worker at a place that made all kinds of stuff out of brass, journeyman diemaker, auto mechanic, now I work in a warehouse. I have learned as much about how not to do things as how to do things.
  • 18
    Font - Neither-Parfait7795 22h no wonder yall hiring, the manager cant even read!" ... 4310 310
  • 19
    Rectangle - Saarnath OP. 20h This is the levity I needed Imao thank you 157
  • 20
    Font - Shicaca44811 - 18h "I'm not angry, but am perplexed and confused to where you based your conclusions. My technical writing experience is very clearly detailed in the resume and documents submitted. In the future I sincerely hope you review the documentation in a more comprehensive fashion to not embarrass yourself with other future potential candidates. At this time I do not believe your lack of attention to detail and management style would mesh with my needs as an employee. I formally r
  • 21
    Rectangle - Elroy Crabs 1d Working for the Weekend Sounds like you dodged a bullet, but it's still lame that she wasted your time and dismissed you like that. ... 229
  • 22
    Font - Saarnath OP. 1d Yeah, better to find out now. And it was kind of funny (in a black humor way) to get her to admit she hadn't even looked at my resume, even though it's messed up they waste people's time like that. 4257
  • 23
    Font - Different-General-23 • 23h She likely did read your resume but she like a lot of hiring managers she doesn't actually understand your qualifications or the needs of the role she's recruiting for. 4104
  • 24
    Rectangle - datagirl60 Or they already had a candidate before posting the position. 22h . ... 449 49
  • 25
    Font - bzzzr. 20h 1 Award Send it to the person they had the first interview with if that interview went well. We had this issue at an old job. Thought we couldn't get anyone qualified to even apply to the position until someone I knew reached out to me directly. Turns out the HR manager didn't understand the job opening and had been rejecting lots of qualified people for months without telling us. 119
  • 26
    Font - Saarnath OP. 20h The thing that sucks is the person I first interviewed with was so nice and polite. So I don't want to get her in trouble or cause some big stir. But that's an interesting point, she may not even be aware that this is happening... I'll consider it. The first person liked me so much she connected with me on LinkedIn immediately after the interview Imao, that's why I was so confused ... 4101
  • 27
    Font - bzzzr • 19h I wouldn't email her and the HR person together or something to cause her a problem. But reaching out to her especially through a non work email like her personal LinkedIn account wouldn't cause her any problems. She can do whatever she wants with that information like talking to her boss or other managers. I still wouldn't work there unless I absolutely loved the department or badly need the work because he is going to have it out for you from day one. 472 ...
  • 28
    Font - SailingSpark. 19h IATSE We have had that same problem in the theatre I work at. The Audio department is aging out and in another couple of years, will all have retired. The current lead has been trying to hire, people he knows that are vastly more experienced than him, and HR keeps rejecting them. When he finally asked them to send people they think are capable, they started sending techs from HVAC, Machine shop, and other completely non-related fields. They saw the word "tech" and went w
  • 29
    Font - unicorn-paid-artist • 17h HR pleebs really have no idea the difference between theatre techs or plumbers. And why those people dont need a bachelors degree. 36
  • 30
    Rectangle - MagnaroftheThenns • 17h This is hilarious. It would be like if a hospital hired a bunch of doctors of philosophy. 33

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article